MASSENA The town has hired an appraisal firm to assist in four commercial assessment challenges.
The Town Council voted unanimously at its August meeting to retain Pomeroy Appraisal Associates Inc., Syracuse, for $26,500. Pomeroy will complete independent appraisals of several commercial properties with assessment challenges. The town needs an independent appraisal completed as evidence in case any of the challenges head to court, according to Assessor Michael C. Ward.
Mr. Ward was confident the town would fare well in the challenges.
Were in very good shape on all of these. Thats why were spending the money, he said. It would be unfair to the homeowners if we didnt pursue these.
Northern New York Newspapers at 1 Harrowgate Commons is seeking a 50 percent reduction from $2,004,400 to $1 million. Harte Haven Shopping Center is attempting to reduce its assessment by more than half, from $5.1 million to $2 million. Walgreens, at Main Street and Route 37, would like to see its assessed value drop from $3.5 million to $2 million. Kent Grove Realty Corp., which owns St. Regis Nursing Home, is petitioning for a reduction from $3,726,000 to $2 million.
We are always evaluating the assessments of our properties in comparison with recent nearby transactions, said Robert D. Gorman, managing editor of the Watertown Daily Times and a spokesman for the Johnson Newspaper Corp., which owns the Massena-Potsdam Daily Courier-Observer and leases the Massena printing plant at Harrowgate Commons on which it pays property tax. The company also owns the Ogdensburg Journal, the St. Lawrence Plain Dealer and the Malone Telegram.
Our assessment should be lowered with regard to what is taking place in Massena with other properties, Mr. Gorman said.
Rebecca M. Speno, an attorney representing the nursing home, said her research determined that propertys assessment was too high.
Were open to having discussions with the town to discuss what their findings are. Its important all parties come to the table and talk, she said. Its just basically about assessment equity and maintaining the integrity of the towns assessment roll.
Supervisor Joseph D. Gray said the challenges, and retaining an appraiser, are a part of doing business in the 21st century. Its not cheap, and theres not a lot of firms that can do it, he said.
Mr. Gray said that four commercial property challenges for one year was not unusual, and that Pomeroy had worked well for the town in the past.
We dont believe our assessments are out of whack, he said. That doesnt stop anyone from challenging it.
The $26,500 comes out of the towns legal fund. Prior to hiring Pomeroy, the town had $42,000 left in the fund in its 2012 budget.
All four properties are near the intersection of Main Street and Route 37, a busy spot that yields valuable real estate, Mr. Gray said. The intersection of Main and 37 are four of the most valuable properties in the county, if not the north country, he said.