A Madrid-Waddington Central School teacher says the state Education Departments changes to standardized assessments expect students to perform far beyond a realistic skill level.
Fourth-grade teacher William Gotsch said this week if school districts dont rally against the changes, students and teachers will suffer as a result.
On Tuesday, Mr. Gotsch asked his districts Board of Education to ask the state to revisit its new education standards after reviewing the state testing programs mathematics common core sample questions on the Education Departments website.
In the new tests, Mr. Gostch says, fourth-graders will be expected to form algebraic equations from multi-step problems and calculate geometric angles at a level too high for fourth-graders to complete.
I had an advanced eighth-grade student take the test. The student could not get through the first two questions, Mr. Gotsch said.
The math test for grades 3 to 8 will be based upon the common core, a curriculum designed to catch U.S. students up with world standards.
I have no problem with the common core, but this test is not the common core, said Mr. Gotsch. I was promised with the common core that we would be able to use manipulatives rulers, protractors and other teaching tools. Instead, our class time is spent reading the textbook. We dont have time for anything else.
Mr. Gotsch said he sent the Internet link to the sample questions, which he says is buried on the education department website, to teachers, parents and administrators in and out of the district to try to garner support for changing the standards.
Madrid-Waddington Superintendent Lynn M. Roy said she will take Mr. Gotschs list of concerns to John B. King Jr., commissioner of education and president of the State University of New York in a meeting in Rochester this week.
These changes are too much, too soon, she said.
In Jefferson County, Indian River Central School Districts Assistant Superintendent Mary Anne Dobmeier said teachers are working hard to make sure teaching matches the standards that will be tested later this year.
Math is going to require a real different set of strategies, she said. There are not a lot of elementary teachers that have a math certification.
The district hired two math coaches through a U.S. Department of Defense education activity grant specifically for elementary and intermediate schools to help improve teachers math skills.
Philip Snyder, a fourth-grade teacher at Hermon-DeKalb Central School, pointed out that changes to the fourth-grade math assessment are being implemented at the same time as the new teacher evaluation system, the Annual Professional Performance Review.
The major changes required for courses like fourth-grade math are requiring extensive training on the teachers part and a whole new way of thinking for students, Mr. Snyder said.
Teachers favorable performance reviews depend in part on how many students pass the standardized tests.
What they have done is caused an incredible amount of anxiety in our teaching ranks and students, said Jamie M. Cruikshank, principal of Potsdam Middle School. We are testing to the point of overload. This is October. My students are already burnt out.
He said he would rather the state implement the changes in stages, allowing the teachers to design a successful curriculum before they are evaluated.
Every one of my teachers has approached me, Mr. Cruikshank said. I have anxiety over the rate of change that the state is asking us to go through.
Mr. Gotsch said his concern is not for himself, but for his students.
If I have kids taking this test in April remember, this is an April test, not a June test I will have kids crying and giving up after the first few questions, he said.
Jonathan Burman, spokesman for the state Education Department, said drastic changes are necessary to ready students for a 21st-century workforce.
The bottom line is that we need to make bold, systemic changes to help all of New Yorks students graduate high school ready for college and careers, he said. The Regents education reforms are essential, and delay only denies our children the best education we can give them.
Mr. Gotsch disagreed.
Our kids are being robbed as we race to try to pass this test, said Mr. Gotsch. I want my kids to be ready for whatever career they want. I dont want school to hold them back.
Johnson Newspaper reporters Reena Singh and Susan Mende contributed to this report.